| Year | Record | Coach | Extra Info |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1907 | 3-0-1 | Arthur “Bun” Brindle | |
| 1908 | 2-3 | Thomas H. Moore | |
| 1909 | 8-0 | Thomas H. Moore | |
| 1910 | 8-1 | Thomas H. Moore | |
| 1911 | 4-2 | Thomas H. Moore | |
| 1912 | 4-3 | Ralph D. Richards | |
| 1913 | 1-4 | Ralph D. Richards | |
| 1914 | 3-5 | Albert J. Allen | |
| 1915 | 8-2 | Albert J. Allen | |
| 1916 | 3-5 | Albert J. Allen | |
| 1917 | 5-3-1 | Paul “Spitz” Ganyard | |
| 1918 | 2-2-1 | Paul “Spitz” Ganyard | |
| 1919 | 3-6 | Harry J. Barnhart | 1st year in North Central Ohio League |
| 1920 | 1-7-1 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1921 | 1-6-1 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1922 | 5-3 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1923 | 2-8 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1924 | 2-7 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1925 | 5-3-1 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1926 | 3-3-2 | Harry J. Barnhart | |
| 1927 | 4-3-1 | Sid Boyd | |
| 1928 | 3-5-1 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1929 | 4-5 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1930 | 6-3-1 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1931 | 4-5 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1932 | 7-1-1 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1933 | 6-2-1 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | |
| 1934 | 7-2-1 | G. Donald “Rosie” Starn | Starn left to become head coach at Kent State |
| 1935 | 5-4-1 | John “Red” Longley | |
| 1936 | 6-2-1 | John “Red” Longley | |
| 1937 | 3-4-2 | John “Red” Longley | |
| 1938 | 4-5 | John “Red” Longley | |
| 1939 | 4-3-2 | John “Red” Longley | |
| 1940 | 3-5-1 | A.L. Buckner | |
| 1941 | 6-1-1 | A.L. Buckner | |
| 1942 | 6-1-1 | A.L. Buckner | |
| 1943 | 5-1-2 | A.L. Buckner | |
| 1944 | 6-2 | A.L. Buckner | |
| 1945 | 2-6-1 | Cloyce E. Taylor | 1st year as an independent |
| 1946 | 6-2-1 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1947 | 8-1 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1948 | 2-7 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1949 | 4-4-1 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1950 | 6-2-1 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1951 | 9-0 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1952 | 9-0 | Cloyce E. Taylor | |
| 1953 | 2-5-2 | Harry Miller | 1st year with Arrows nickname |
| 1954 | 1-7-1 | Harry Miller | |
| 1955 | 2-7 | Jack Powell | |
| 1956 | 2-7 | Jack Powell | |
| 1957 | 1-8 | Jack Powell | |
| 1958 | 2-7 | John Hogan | |
| 1959 | 4-5 | John Hogan | |
| 1960 | 1-7-1 | John Hogan | 1st year in Cardinal Conference |
| 1961 | 0-9 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1962 | 4-5 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1963 | 9-0 | Lloyd Dunne | 1st year playing in Community Stadium |
| 1964 | 8-1 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1965 | 8-1 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1966 | 4-3-2 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1967 | 4-5 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1968 | 4-5 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1969 | 4-4-1 | Lloyd Dunne | |
| 1970 | 1-8 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1971 | 7-1-1 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1972 | 7-1-1 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1973 | 5-3-1 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1974 | 5-4 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1975 | 3-6 | Paul Dienstberger | |
| 1976 | 1-9 | Ed Bush | |
| 1977 | 1-9 | Ed Bush | |
| 1978 | 4-5-1 | Dave Gray | |
| 1979 | 3-6-1 | Dave Gray | |
| 1980 | 2-8 | Dave Gray | |
| 1981 | 2-8 | Dave Gray | |
| 1982 | 1-9 | Larry Baldridge | |
| 1983 | 2-8 | Larry Baldridge | |
| 1984 | 2-8 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1985 | 6-4 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1986 | 7-3 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1987 | 7-4 | Bob Quackenbush | First-ever playoff appearance, 1st year in Ohio Heartland Conference |
| 1988 | 6-4 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1989 | 0-10 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1990 | 2-8 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1991 | 5-5 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1992 | 7-3 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1993 | 2-8 | Bob Quackenbush | |
| 1994 | 7-3 | Dick James | |
| 1995 | 5-5 | Dick James | |
| 1996 | 5-5 | Dick James | |
| 1997 | 5-5 | Dick James | |
| 1998 | 6-4 | Dick James | |
| 1999 | 5-5 | Dick James | |
| 2000 | 1-9 | Dick James | |
| 2001 | 1-9 | Dick James | |
| 2002 | 6-4 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2003 | 8-3 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Quarterfinals, 1st year in Ohio Cardinal Conference |
| 2004 | 7-3 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2005 | 5-5 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2006 | 12-1 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Finals, 100th football season |
| 2007 | 12-2 | Scott Valentine | D-II State Semifinals |
| 2008 | 4-6 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2009 | 11-2 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Finals |
| 2010 | 10-3 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Finals |
| 2011 | 6-5 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Quarterfinals |
| 2012 | 6-4 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2013 | 7-3 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2014 | 6-5 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Quarterfinals |
| 2015 | 9-2 | Scott Valentine | D-III Regional Quarterfinals |
| 2016 | 7-4 | Scott Valentine | D-III Regional Quarterfinals |
| 2017 | 9-3 | Scott Valentine | D-II Regional Semifinals |
| 2018 | 5-5 | Scott Valentine | |
| 2019 | 4-6 | Sean Seder | |
| 2020 | 8-2 | Sean Seder | D-III Regional Semifinals |
| 2021 | 3-7 | Sean Seder | |
| 2022 | 6-5 | Sean Seder | Regional Quarterfinals |
| 2023 | 5-6 | Scott Valentine | Playoffs |
| 2024 | 12-1 | Scott Valentine | Playoffs |